What to Eat
Downtown Mayville offers a variety of dining options sure to please any palate. If you’re in the mood for Chinese food, New China Chinese Restaurant serves up a selection of tasty dishes. For those craving Mexican flavors, Don Ramon's Mexican Restaurant provides a welcoming atmosphere and flavorful meals. The Nest Eatery is a great spot for casual dining, with delicious pizzas and sandwiches perfect for a laid-back lunch or dinner.
Looking for something made fresh and wholesome? The Natural Way Eatery features locally sourced ingredients with vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options, all thoughtfully crafted by Chef Earl on a limited rotating menu.
If it’s comfort food you’re after, Richie’s UR Alley is a local favorite known for its Friday Fish Fry, homemade pizzas, and rotating weekend specials. Sidelines Tap is the place to go for what Chris proudly calls the *best wings this side of the Rock River*, plus burgers, appetizers, and a game-day atmosphere with 12 TVs. Atwell’s Pub is another great option, serving up delicious pizzas, a classic fish fry, and hearty comfort food favorites in a relaxed, friendly setting.
Cardinal Lanes Bowling Alley combines food and fun, offering a menu of classic American fare to enjoy while you bowl.
Open Door Coffeehouse + Restaurant is more than just a place to grab a great cup of coffee—it’s a cozy, welcoming spot serving up delicious breakfast and lunch small plates. Their menu features freshly made options like quiches, breakfast sandwiches, salads, and baked goods, with seasonal soups and specials that keep things fresh and flavorful throughout the year. Whether you're meeting a friend, grabbing a quick bite, or settling in to relax, Open Door is a perfect downtown stop.
Sweet Pea's Pies and Ice Cream is a delightful destination for anyone with a sweet tooth. They offer hand-dipped ice cream in a variety of classic and rotating flavors, along with fresh, made-from-scratch pies that taste just like home. From fruit pies to creamy favorites and seasonal specialties, Sweet Pea’s is a must-visit. You’ll also find other treats and local goodies that make it the perfect place to stop in and satisfy your cravings.
Explore the dining scene in downtown Mayville—you’re sure to find something delicious around every corner!
​